Amar’e Stoudemire’s Poor Pick And Roll Defense | NBA Playbook

Amar’e Stoudemire’s Poor Pick And Roll Defense

The Lakers ran a ton of pick and rolls in game 2 with Pau Gasol as the screen man for most of them.  This allowed the Lakers to take advantage of Amar’e Stoudemire’s poor pick and roll defense since he was the Sun usually responsible for defending Pau Gasol.

Defending The Ball Handler

Now Stoudemire wasn’t asked to defend the ball handler coming off the pick and roll too much, but when he was, he didn’t do a very good job of it.

In the above video, Jason Richardson gets caught in the Pau Gasol screen, forcing Stoudemire to defend Ron Artest.  When you are defending the ball-handler on the pick and roll, the ultimate goal is to prevent him from getting where he wants to go with a hard hedge.  Stoudemire doesn’t hedge hard at all, allowing Ron Artest to basically walk to the elbow and knock down an easy jumper.

1

Even though Artest isn’t really a threat to attack the basket, Amar’e plays off of him and even as he is squaring up (shown in the screenshot above), Amar’e doesn’t get his hands up to try and effect the shot.

Defending The Roll Man

This is where Amar’e Stoudemire really struggled.  One of Stoudemire’s biggest problems is that once he comes out and hedges and prevents the ball handler from getting to his spot, he thinks his job is over.  He doesn’t bust his ass to get back to the roll man, but instead he causally tries to get back to him as if there is no way the roll man is a threat to get the basketball:

In both of instances shown above, the initial pick and roll defense is good.  Amar’e Stoudemire hedges out, preventing the ball handler to get where he wants to go.  Soudemire never finishes the job, and in both of the PNR situations, the Lakers are able to wait…and wait…until Gasol gets to the rim before they get in the pass.  In fact in the first instance, the pass isn’t even made directly to Gasol, it goes from Kobe to Odom then to Gasol, and Stoudemire still isn’t even a factor in the play.

To me, it all comes down to being willing to work hard on defense.  Ama’re Stoudemire has the physical tools to be a good defender because of his length and quickness, he just doesn’t use it.  And while the two above plays were bad, the one I am about to show really displays Amar’e's laziness on the defensive end.

Amar’e Stoudemire shows way too early, as if to get a head start on his hedge.  Kobe simply waits until Pau slips the screen and then hits him for the easy lay-up.

RM1

Looking at the screenshot, there is no reason whatsoever for Amar’e being that high on his show before Kobe even dribbles the basketball.    He is basically inviting Pau Gasol to slip the screen here.  Steve Nash is in pretty good help position, but eventually he has to leave the lane to avoid a defensive three seconds call.  As soon as he does, Gasol slips the screen and gets the pass.

20
May 2010
POSTED BY
DISCUSSION 19 Comments
TAGS

  • http://givemetherock.com Nels

    While the first examples clearly demonstrate Amar’e's lack of hustle on defense, the last one makes me wonder about his basketball IQ. Why is he standing all the way out there? He’s not fast enough to jump out and show on Kobe real quick? He just doesn’t even seem to be thinking on that play. They’re down 9 with 4 minutes left in a playoff game. His team needs stops, not playground ball.

  • Kamron

    Have to say, Artest shooting from just inside the 3pt line is probably a good shot for the Suns; not that Amare did that intentionally. The rest is just awful; this is just not footage of a basketball player who really wants to win the game. It’s one thing to see a defender miscue while displaying good effort, it’s just shameful to see a talented player and ostensible team leader display this sort of boredom with the idea of playing defense.
    Nels, I think he’s standing out there because standing there is less effort than jumping out when Kobe actually makes his move. He needs to preserve his legs for making SportsCenter highlights at the other end, he can’t go wasting his energy like that.

  • justin

    more than not wanting to waste his legs or whatever, I think he’s genuinely unfocused/unaware of what he’s supposed to be doing. Some of that might come back on the PHX coaching staff, but ultimately a player in the league that long should understand basic pick and roll defense, and as hinted above, be mentally locked in with 4 minutes to go in a playoff game. Stou*amire’s lack o’ D plus the two uncharacteristic Nash turnovers in the early 4Q essentially wasted the Suns best chance to steal a game in LA, and thus win the series. They aren’t getting a Jared Dudley 5-5 3FG or a 14 point Grant Hill 3Q again.

    SP, great site.

  • Dyllan Wineera

    @Nels
    Amare could have trapped if he had yelled at Barbosa to get there, but the lack of communication left Barbosa worried about Kobe burning him baseline. One of those 2 needed to make the decision, but LBB just sits there hands down no ball pressure and Amare stands in no man’s land…..Seb is right. They need to start hustling and playing with some god damn energy on the defensive end as we all know they can and have seen them do in the previous rounds, or its good night PHX.

  • aditya

    excellent work….his defence is horrible…..max contract? r u kidding me?

  • vilnas

    Further evidence of low basketball IQ is Stoudemire’s foul on Gasol in the last clip. He casually reaches out and hits Gasol’s left arm as he goes up for the right handed lay in. It is a bit hard to see in this clip, but I remember it clearly from the telecast last night. It was an obvious foul that had to be called, yet had no impact whatsoever on Gasol’s ability to make the easy lay up.

  • http://johnharrisbasketball.com John

    That last clip is laughable. I got 14 year olds who know better than that.

  • ed j

    I was the last person to say Amare should be traded but now i am convinced he has to go. Too much money is being spent on him. Suns need a good big man. Amare considers himself a power forward and thus refuses to do anything but showcase his once in a while hammer dunks. He cant even create his own unless Nash sets him up. Frye has serious work ethic he wants to shoot but with his size he should be defending the basket he shys away from that.Trade him off also. We need someone loke Camby or Chandler with some guts to play defense. Lopez start to improve gain some muscle or adios carnal!

  • james

    amar”””e stou-emire: cursed be the team who giveth him a max contract, for they will be rewarded the very same year with a pick in the lottery

    i found that written on an ancient tablet, those things have a habit of coming true

  • http://valleyofthesuns.com/2010/05/20/suns-lakers-across-the-nation-may-20/ Links from across the nation after the Suns fell into a 2-0 hole to the Lakers| Valley of the Suns

    [...] Pruiti of TrueHoop sister blog NBA Playbook breaks down Amare Stoudemire’s defense (or lack there of) against the pick and roll: “The Lakers ran a ton of pick and rolls in game [...]

  • Jim becker

    Gasol was just lucky.

  • Tidal

    @Jim becker
    This comment is freakin gold! Priceless!

  • Rywiby

    I wonder what the converation between gentry and amare was like in film session. Gentry: “uhm… Did you happen to see the 7 foot caveman from Spain. Horrific white flailing limbs? Big nasty catchers mitt face? What? No? I guess he is kind’ve easy to miss”

  • S A K

    Do you mind to also discuss Lakers Pick and Roll defense wih 3 men by which they didn’t allow Suns to take advantage of their PNR with Nash as they usually do.

  • Anders

    Oh boy was the Gasol/Odom hedge on one end the extreme opposite of Amare´s. Gasol and Odom played teriffic P&R defense, while Amare just coasted all night.

    His lack of hustle actually surprises me, he had been playing somewhat solid lately on that end (relatively). I was wondering at the end of game 2, if Gentry could have just swapped him for Lopez.

    Lopez was solid on offense also, where Amare seemed to struggle with the long and punishing Lakres frontcourt.

  • gilad

    great basetball IQ from the Lakers as well. waiting for Nash to clear the lane before slipping.

  • Bottle

    I remembered how TNTs colour man harped on Amare's laziness so much on the last play being shown in this article.

  • Bottle

    I remembered how TNTs colour man harped on Amare’s laziness so much on the last play being shown in this article.

  • Bottle

    I remembered how TNTs colour man harped on Amare's laziness so much on the last play being shown in this article.